Nature's Variety Selected Junior Chicken vs Edgard & Cooper Puppy Duck & Chicken

Pros

• ✓Named free-range chicken as primary protein — no generic meat derivatives, by-products or meat meal
• ✓Fish oil provides natural DHA, meeting developmental needs for puppy brain, vision and nervous system maturation
• ✓Consistently high palatability reported across multiple reviewers and dog breeds over long periods
• ✓Free from artificial colours, preservatives and flavourings — clean label for a growing puppy

Cons

• ✗At least one reviewer reported a possible recipe reformulation removing chicken inclusions, with no response from the brand — ingredient consistency should be verified
• ✗Full ingredient list and guaranteed analysis not provided, making precise FEDIAF compliance (calcium:phosphorus ratio, crude protein %) difficult to confirm
• ✗Premium price point flagged as high relative to perceived value after suspected reformulation
• ✗Occasional Amazon fulfilment errors reported (wrong product or wrong size delivered) — not a product fault, but worth ordering directly from trusted retailers

Best For

Pros

• ✓Named meat sources (duck and chicken) — no generic by-products or meat meal
• ✓Grain-free and natural formula with no over-processed or dried meat
• ✓Prebiotics included to support healthy gut development in puppies
• ✓Strong palatability reported by fussy-dog owners switching from other premium brands

Cons

• ✗Palatability is inconsistent — a minority of dogs flatly refuse it with no clear pattern
• ✗150g portion sizes are small for large-breed puppies (25–45 kg), requiring multiple cups per meal
• ✗Grain-free formulas for large-breed puppies require careful calcium/phosphorus balancing — not always verifiable from marketing copy alone
• ✗Some non-English reviews suggest this product is widely distributed internationally but reviewed outside UK context, diluting UK-specific palatability signal

Best For