Forthglade Variety Pack Chicken vs Scrumbles Turkey Wet

Pros

• ✓75% named chicken or turkey — high, transparent meat inclusion with no by-products or meat meal
• ✓Excellent track record for sensitive stomachs, digestive issues, and food intolerances reported across multiple reviews
• ✓Grain-free with nutrient-dense vegetable carbohydrates (sweet potato, butternut squash) supporting digestibility
• ✓Clean, transparent ingredient labelling — no vague 'meat derivatives' or artificial additives

Cons

• ✗Occasional texture inconsistency between batches (pâté vs. crumbly vs. jelly-like) reported by owners on subscription
• ✗Not suitable for dogs with poultry allergies — all three flavours are chicken or turkey based
• ✗Premium price point compared to mainstream wet foods; value per kg is moderate for the quality tier
• ✗Isolated packaging leakage reports suggesting tray seal quality control could be improved

Best For

Pros

• ✓65% named turkey with no by-products or meat meal — transparent, high-quality protein sourcing
• ✓Slippery elm inclusion provides evidence-based gut support, particularly for IBD and sensitive stomachs
• ✓Exceptional palatability — multiple reviewers note even very fussy or medically sensitive dogs eat it enthusiastically
• ✓Grain-free and hypoallergenic formulation reduces common dietary triggers

Cons

• ✗Foil lid frequently reported as difficult to open and prone to splattering
• ✗Elevated dry-matter fat (~46%) may be unsuitable for dogs with pancreatitis or obesity
• ✗150g pouches require multiple units per day for medium to large breeds, increasing cost
• ✗Limited protein variety in the range (no beef option noted by reviewers)

Best For