Pro Plan Medium Puppy Chicken vs Lily's Kitchen Puppy Chicken Wet

Pros

• ✓Named chicken as #1 ingredient — no by-products, no meat meal
• ✓Colostrum inclusion supports immune defences and gut microbiome in young puppies
• ✓Excellent palatability across multiple breeds, including reported fussy eaters
• ✓Complete and balanced for puppy growth — DHA, Vitamin D, calcium/phosphorus ratios for bone and joint development

Cons

• ✗Premium pricing with a small 3kg pack — cost per kg is high compared to mid-market alternatives
• ✗Full ingredient list not disclosed in listing — likely contains grain-based carbohydrate fillers (corn, wheat, rice) typical of Pro Plan formulas
• ✗Sized and formulated for medium breeds (10–25kg); several reviewers using it for toy/small breeds, which is an off-label use
• ✗Oversized cardboard packaging noted as wasteful by buyers

Best For

Pros

• ✓Named chicken as primary protein — freshly prepared, not rendered or meal-based per brand claims
• ✓Visible meat, vegetables, and herbs reported by owners; no jelly filler like cheaper alternatives
• ✓Excellent palatability — most dogs eat eagerly and show excitement at feeding time
• ✓No reported digestive issues; well-tolerated across multiple reviews

Cons

• ✗Premium price point — among the more expensive puppy wet foods per 100g; several reviewers flag cost as a barrier
• ✗Portion size per tray (150g) may be insufficient as sole feeding for larger breed puppies, requiring multiple trays per meal
• ✗A small number of dogs lost interest after initial enthusiasm — palatability may not be consistent long-term for fussy eaters
• ✗Spec data indicates meat meal present, which contradicts brand marketing claims — ingredient list should be verified on-pack before purchase

Best For