Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie vs Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon
Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie and Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon.
Last verified: 01 Mar 2026 · Based on 26 reviews
Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie scores 81.0/100 vs Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon at 81.0/100. Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie wins on ingredient quality, palatability. Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon is stronger on value for money and transparency.
How Do the Scores Compare?
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adul...
Lily's Kitchen
|
Pooch & Mutt - Health & Dig...
Pooch & Mu
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 81.0 | 81.0 |
| Ingredient Quality |
86.0/100
Best
|
84.0/100 |
| Nutritional Value |
78.0/100
Best
|
78.0/100
Best
|
| Value for Money | 62.0/100 |
66.0/100
Best
|
| Transparency | 88.0/100 |
89.0/100
Best
|
| Palatability |
93.0/100
Best
|
90.0/100 |
| Best Price | £14.40 Amazon UK → |
£15.99
£12.79
Amazon UK →
-20% deal
|
| Form | ||
| Dose | ||
| Third-Party Tested | ✗ No | ✗ No |
| Reviews Analysed | 13 | 13 |
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet...
Pros
- ✓Named beef protein source — no generic 'meat derivatives' or anonymous by-products
- ✓Exceptionally high palatability: multiple reviewers report enthusiastic eating, improved coat condition, and no digestive upset
- ✓Grain-free with whole vegetables (carrot, broccoli, green beans) providing natural micronutrients
- ✓No artificial flavourings, colourings, or preservatives; transparent ingredient labelling
Cons
- ✗Grain-free diets with legume/potato bases remain under FDA/WSAVA scrutiny for a potential link to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM); not conclusive but worth monitoring long-term
- ✗Premium price point — significantly more expensive per kg than mainstream wet foods
- ✗150g tray is a single meal for small dogs only; large breeds (25–45 kg per spec) require 3–4 trays per meal, making daily cost considerable
- ✗One isolated report of a potentially spoiled batch; not a pattern but worth noting for quality-control awareness
Best For
Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestio...
Pros
- ✓45% named salmon as single protein source — high digestibility, rich in omega-3s, ideal for elimination diets
- ✓Prebiotics included to actively support gut flora balance, not just passive fibre
- ✓Exceptionally high palatability — accepted by picky and fussy dogs across multiple breeds
- ✓Completely free from grains, gluten, by-products, meat meal, and artificial additives — strong ingredient transparency
Cons
- ✗Premium price point — above average cost per kg compared to mainstream grain-free options
- ✗Occasional reports of skin itching, consistent with individual salmon protein sensitivity
- ✗Grain-free formulas remain under ongoing veterinary and FDA scrutiny for potential links to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in some breeds
- ✗2kg pack size offers relatively poor value per kg for medium-to-large breeds with higher daily feeding volumes
Best For
Score Breakdown: Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie vs Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon
Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie is a premium grain-free wet food featuring named beef as the primary protein alongside a visible array of whole vegetables (carrot, broccoli, green beans, potato) and herbs, with no artificial additives or vague 'meat derivatives'.
What are the key differences?
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie or Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon? ▼
Is Lily's Kitchen Cottage Pie worth the price compared to Pooch & Mutt Health & Digestion Salmon? ▼
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Related Product Comparisons
Complete Natural Adult Dog Food Wet (10 x 150g Trays)
vs Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tray Cottage Pie Grain-Free Recipe 10 x 150g
Complete Natural Adult Dog Food Wet (10 x 150g Trays)
vs Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestion, Complete Dry Dog Food (Grain Free), Salmon and Sweet Potato, 2kg
Lily's Kitchen Made with Natural Ingredients Adult Small Breed Dry Dog Food Chicken & Duck Grain-Free Recipe 2.5kg
vs Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tray Cottage Pie Grain-Free Recipe 10 x 150g
Lily's Kitchen Made with Natural Ingredients Adult Small Breed Dry Dog Food Chicken & Duck Grain-Free Recipe 2.5kg
vs Pooch & Mutt - Health & Digestion, Complete Dry Dog Food (Grain Free), Salmon and Sweet Potato, 2kg
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tray Cottage Pie Grain-Free Recipe 10 x 150g
vs Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Classic Dinners Variety Pack 6 x 400g & Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tins Grain-Free Recipe Variety Pack 6 x 400g
Lily's Kitchen Natural Adult Wet Dog Food Tray Cottage Pie Grain-Free Recipe 10 x 150g
vs Burns Pet Nutrition Sensitive Grain Free Duck and Potato Adult Dry Dog Food, 2 kg
What the Data Says
Is grain-free dog food actually better? What the data shows.
Grain-free leads on every metric, but the gap is smaller than marketing suggests. We scored 27 grain-free and 73 standard dry dog foods across the same criteria.
The numbers: grain-free averages 75.1/100 overall versus 71.5 for standard — a 3.6-point lead. Break it down by category and the picture gets more interesting.
Ingredient quality is where grain-free pulls ahead most: 77.8 versus 71.2, a 6.6-point gap. Grain-free brands tend to use higher meat content and fewer cheap bulking agents. Transparency is the second-largest gap: 74.9 versus 69.8 (5.1 points) — grain-free brands are generally more upfront about sourcing and ingredient percentages.
But nutritional value tells a different story: 72.1 versus 70.0, just 2.1 points apart. That's the smallest gap of any metric. Removing grains doesn't automatically make a food more nutritious.
Bottom line: if your dog has a diagnosed grain intolerance, grain-free is the right call. If not, a high-scoring standard food delivers nearly identical nutrition at a lower price point.
Do grain-free dog foods hide carbohydrate fillers?
Grain-free scores better on transparency (74.9 vs 69.8), but grain-free does not mean low-carb. That 5.1-point transparency gap across 27 grain-free and 73 standard products means grain-free brands are more likely to disclose ingredient percentages and sourcing details.
The catch: most grain-free formulas replace rice, wheat, or corn with peas, lentils, chickpeas, or sweet potato. These are still carbohydrate sources. Some grain-free products list two or three legume variants in the first five ingredients, pushing total carbohydrate content to 40-50% of the formula.
Here's how to check: read the analytical constituents on the back of the bag. If protein is 25% and fat is 15%, the remaining 60% is mostly carbohydrates, moisture, and fibre. That's true whether the carbs come from brown rice or sweet potato.
The grain-free label tells you what's absent, not what replaced it. Higher transparency scores mean these brands make it easier for you to verify the substitution yourself — but you still need to look.
Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Feedback & Suggestions
Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.
Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.